A few years ago, I wrote a history of the struggle for gay and lesbian rights in a volume for the National Library of Australia. The tone was celebratory, reflecting the spirit of the times.
When the issue of trans rights emerged, slowly at first then exploding in the late 2010s, I saw it as a natural evolution of the gay and lesbian rights movement. It made sense to add the T to LGB to recognise another marginalised group that had found its voice. I had known a couple of older transwomen; of course they deserved respect and freedom from discrimination.
Like most, I was hazy about what transsexuality and transgender really meant and the way in which the idea of gender had been adopted from feminism and reinterpreted, in fact, turned upside down.
Even so, in the early 2020s I became disturbed by the growing intolerance of any non-conforming view. The brutal treatment by her peers of Kathleen Stock, a philosophy professor at my alma mater, the University of Sussex, shocked me. But I kept the dispute at arm’s length. To be honest, I was afraid of doing something that might earn the wrath of the activists and make me a target.
I’m not usually afraid to go where left-wing angels fear to tread—I’d been the target of vicious zealotry in the past—but I was too uncertain of my ground. Developing a coherent position on the trans issue would require work, and there were other matters occupying me.
However, my irritation with transactivist bullying escalated as more and more cases emerged of reasonable people being vilified, threatened, cancelled and fired simply for taking an alternative view to that of the hard-liners. I was mystified by the vehemence of the attacks on J.K. Rowling simply for arguing that, while they deserve respect, transwomen are not women and single-sex spaces are sometimes justified. You may disagree with her, but what she was saying seemed perfectly defensible from a feminist standpoint.
The righteous burning of Harry Potter books, as if they had become contaminated, had historical parallels and signalled to me the cultural triumph of the evangelical left.
Source: My Trans Flip, or how I went from foggy brained to clear-eyed on gender ideology
